Rangkuman “Top Ten Films of 2010” (Critics & Bloggers)

Berikut kritikus dan blogger film yang telah mengumumkan top ten-nya. Daftar ini juga saya tempatkan di sidebar, jadi untuk yang ingin mengecek update terbaru silakan bisa langsung berkunjung ke postingan ini. Sekaligus melihat referensi dari para kritikus dan blogger mengenai film yang mereka sukai di tahun 2010 ini. Silakan menyimak!

Lihat hasil tabulasi sementara untuk situs film independen Indiewire.com.

Lihat juga hasil tabulasi di Metacritic.

Top Ten Films of the Year

[updated: December 19, 2010]

Armond White (New York Press)

[list]

  1. Scott Pilgrim vs. the World
  2. Vincere
  3. Wild Grass
  4. Mother and Child
  5. Life During Wartime
  6. Another Year
  7. Inspector Bellamy
  8. The Girl on the Train
  9. Takers
  10. From Paris With Love

Cedric Succivalli (ICS)

[list]

  1. Carlos
  2. Our Beloved Month of August
  3. Alamar
  4. Vincere
  5. Another Year
  6. A Prophet
  7. Secret Sunshine
  8. The Ghost Writer
  9. White Material
  10. Everyone Else

Eric Hynes (Reverse Shot)

[list]

  1. Everyone Else
  2. Carlos
  3. I Am Love
  4. Mother
  5. Another Year
  6. White Material
  7. Secret Sunshine
  8. Alamar
  9. Easy A
  10. The Social Network

Peter Knegt (IndieWire)

[list]

  1. Another Year
  2. Everyone Else
  3. I Am Love
  4. Dogtooth
  5. Carlos
  6. The Ghost Writer
  7. True Grit
  8. Black Swan
  9. Last Train Home
  10. The Kids Are All Right

Roger Ebert (Chicago Sun Times)

[commentary]

  1. The Social Network
  2. The King’s Speech
  3. Black Swan
  4. I Am Love
  5. Winter’s Bone
  6. Inception
  7. The Secret in Their Eyes
  8. The American
  9. The Kids Are All Right
  10. The Ghost Writer

The New York Times

Stephen Holden (New York Times)

[commentary]

  1. The Social Network
  2. Inside Job
  3. Inception
  4. Carlos
  5. Another Year
  6. Vincere
  7. White Material
  8. The Kids Are All Right
  9. True Grit
  10. My Dog Tulip

Manohla Dargis (New York Times)

[commentary]

[unranked 30 films]

  • “Sweetgrass” (Ilisa Barbash and Lucien Castaing-Taylor)
  • “The Ghost Writer” (Roman Polanski)
  • “Shutter Island” (Martin Scorsese)
  • “A Prophet” (Jacques Audiard)
  • “Vincere” (Marco Bellocchio)
  • “Everyone Else” (Maren Ade)
  • “Joan Rivers: A Piece of Work” (Ricki Stern and Annie Sundberg)
  • “Wild Grass” (Alain Resnais)
  • “The Kids Are All Right” (Lisa Cholodenko)
  • “Inception” (Christopher Nolan)
  • “A Film Unfinished” (Yael Hersonski)
  • “The Tillman Story” (Amir Bar-Lev)
  • “Mesrine: Public Enemy No. 1” (Jean-François Richet)
  • “Last Train Home” (Lixin Fan)
  • “Enter the Void” (Gaspar Noé)
  • three shorts by Nathaniel Dorsky (“Aubade,” “Compline” and “Pastourelle”)
  • “Get Out of the Car” (Thom Andersen)
  • “The Social Network” (David Fincher)
  • “A Loft” (Ken Jacobs)
  • “Inside Job” (Charles Ferguson)
  • “Carlos” (Olivier Assayas)
  • “Boxing Gym” (Frederick Wiseman)
  • “127 Hours” (Danny Boyle)
  • “Tiny Furniture” (Lena Dunham)
  • “Guy and Madeline on a Park Bench” (Damien Chazelle)
  • “White Material” (Claire Denis)
  • “Black Swan” (Darren Aronofsky)
  • “The Fighter” (David O. Russell)
  • “True Grit” (Joel and Ethan Coen)
  • “Secret Sunshine” (Lee Chang-dong)
  • “The Strange Case of Angelica” (Manoel de Oliveira)

Robert Horton (The Herald)

[list]

  1. A Prophet
  2. Winter’s Bone
  3. Four Lions
  4. Sweetgrass
  5. The Ghost Writer
  6. Eccentricities of a Blonde-Haired Girl
  7. Mid-August Lunch
  8. The Kids Are All Right
  9. Soul Kitchen
  10. Greenberg

Karina Longworth (LA Weekly)

[list]

  1. Trash Humpers
  2. Greenberg
  3. Daddy Longlegs
  4. Dogtooth
  5. Somewhere
  6. The Red Chapel
  7. Everyone Else
  8. Shutter Island
  9. The Ghost Writer
  10. Enter the Void

Film Comment

[full list]

  1. Carlos, Olivier Assayas
  2. The Social Network, David Fincher
  3. White Material, Claire Denis
  4. The Ghost Writer, Roman Polanski
  5. A Prophet, Jacques Audiard
  6. Winter’s Bone, Debra Granik
  7. Inside Job, Charles Ferguson
  8. Wild Grass, Alain Resnais
  9. Everyone Else, Maren Ade
  10. Greenberg, Noah Baumbach

Amy Taubin (Film Comment)

[list]

  1. Wild Grass
  2. The Social Network
  3. White Material
  4. And Everything Is Going Fine
  5. Guy and Madeline on a Park Bench
  6. Inside Job
  7. The Strange Case of Angelica
  8. Another Year
  9. Bluebeard
  10. Wah Do Dem

The AV Club (writer’s poll)

[commentary]

  1. Winter’s Bone
  2. The Social Network
  3. Black Swan
  4. Inception
  5. Exit Through The Gift Shop
  6. Toy Story 3
  7. Mother
  8. Carlos
  9. A Prophet
  10. True Grit
  11. Greenberg
  12. Dogtooth
  13. Scott Pilgrim vs. The World
  14. Shutter Island
  15. The Kids Are Alright

(individual list)

Noel Murray (The AV Club)

[link]

  1. Black Swan
  2. Winter’s Bone
  3. The Social Network
  4. Mother
  5. The Illusionist
  6. Greenberg
  7. Inception
  8. Carlos
  9. Dogtooth
  10. True Grit

Keith Phipps (The AV Club)

[link]

  1. Winter’s Bone
  2. Black Swan
  3. The Social Network
  4. Inception
  5. Toy Story 3
  6. True Grit
  7. Exit Through The Gift Shop”
  8. Mother
  9. Rabbit Hole
  10. Carlos

Nathan Rabin (The AV Club)

[link]

  1. Blue Valentine
  2. Black Swan
  3. Greenberg
  4. Best Worst Movie
  5. Inception
  6. Exit Through The Gift Shop
  7. The Social Network
  8. The King’s Speech
  9. True Grit
  10. Scott Pilgrim Vs. The World

Tasha Robinson (The AV Club)

[link]

  1. Inception
  2. The Social Network
  3. Scott Pilgrim Vs. The World
  4. Black Swan
  5. Toy Story 3
  6. Winter’s Bone
  7. A Prophet
  8. Another Year
  9. Red Riding Trilogy
  10. Mother

Scott Tobias (The AV Club)

[link]

  1. Dogtooth
  2. Winter’s Bone
  3. Carlos
  4. The Social Network
  5. Exit Through The Gift Shop
  6. Everyone Else
  7. Shutter Island
  8. Mother
  9. Toy Story 3
  10. Restrepo

Kris Tapley (In Contention)

[commentary]

  1. Exit through the Gift Shop
  2. Another Year
  3. A Prophet
  4. Shutter Island
  5. Black Swan
  6. The Social Network
  7. Enter the Void
  8. Catfish
  9. Toy Story 3
  10. The Way Back

Anne Thompson (Thompson on Hollywood)

[commentary]

  1. Winter’s Bone
  2. The Kids Are Alright
  3. The Social Network
  4. Toy Story 3
  5. Inside Job
  6. The King’s Speech
  7. Let Me In
  8. Carlos
  9. True Grit
  10. Fish Tank

Joshua Rothkopf (Time Out New York)

[the list]

  1. The Social Network
  2. Exit Through the Gift Shop
  3. Carlos
  4. Another Year
  5. Winter’s Bone
  6. Dogtooth
  7. The Kids Are All Right
  8. Lourdes
  9. A Prophet
  10. 127 Hours

Eric Kohn (Indiewire)

[the list]

  1. Dogtooth
  2. Exit Through the Gift Shop
  3. Winter’s Bone
  4. Daddy Longlegs
  5. Another Year
  6. Animal Kingdom
  7. Catfish
  8. Alamar
  9. Prince of Broadway
  10. Enter the Void

Michael Koresky (Reverse Shot)

[the list]

  1. Mother
  2. Alamar
  3. Another Year
  4. White Material
  5. Everyone Else
  6. Secret Sunshine
  7. The Strange Case of Angelica
  8. Eccentricities of a Blonde-Haired Girl
  9. Dogtooth
  10. Hadewijch

Jeff Reichert (Reverse Shot)

[the list]

  1. Another Year
  2. Our Beloved Month of August
  3. Alamar
  4. WIld Grass
  5. Eccentricities of a Blonde-Haired Girl
  6. Mother
  7. Change Nothing
  8. Around a Small Mountain
  9. White Material
  10. Hadewijch

Nick Schager (Slant Magazine)

[the list]

  1. Lourdes
  2. Everyone Else
  3. Dogtooth
  4. Scott Pilgrim vs. the World
  5. Secret Sunshine
  6. Mother
  7. October Country
  8. The Social Network
  9. Prodigal Sons
  10. Winter’s Bone

Ed Gonzalez (Slant Magazine)

[the list]

  1. Everyone Else
  2. Secret Sunshine
  3. The Ghost Writer
  4. October Country
  5. Prodigal Sons
  6. Winter’s Bone
  7. Mother
  8. 45365
  9. The Social Network
  10. Ondine

Alison Willmore (IFC.com)

[the list]

  1. Everyone Else
  2. Secret Sunshine
  3. The Ghost Writer
  4. October Country
  5. Prodigal Sons
  6. Winter’s Bone
  7. Mother
  8. 45365
  9. The Social Network
  10. Ondine

Tom Hall (Sarasota Film Festival)

[the list]

  1. Blue Valentine
  2. Hadewjich
  3. The Social Network
  4. Carlos
  5. Black Swan
  6. Everyone Else
  7. And Everything Is Going Fine
  8. Alamar
  9. Rabbit Hole
  10. Winter’s Bone

Mark Olsen (Frelance at Film Comment & LA Times)

[the list]

  1. Greenberg
  2. Black Swan
  3. Trash Humpers
  4. The Social Network
  5. Four Lions
  6. Shutter Island
  7. Carlos
  8. Daddy Longlegs
  9. The Oath
  10. Animal Kingdom

Adam Nayman (Eye Weekly)

[the list]

  1. Alamar
  2. Everyone Else
  3. Mother
  4. The Social Network
  5. Sweetgrass
  6. The Ghost Writer
  7. Secret Sunshine
  8. Unstoppable
  9. The Anchorage
  10. Buried

Melissa Anderson (Village Voice)

[the list]

  1. Carlos
  2. Lourdes
  3. World on a Wire
  4. Lebanon
  5. The Social Network
  6. White Material
  7. Alamar
  8. Night Catches Us
  9. Daddy Longlegs
  10. I Love You Phillip Morris

*berikut list dari staf The L Magazine, ini merupakan majalah gratis di New York yang mengupas seni, budaya, hiburan, dll.

Mark Asch (The L Magazine)

[commentary]

  1. Carlos
  2. Wild Grass
  3. Everyone Else
  4. Dogtooth
  5. White Material
  6. Warwencol
  7. The Father of My Children
  8. Greenberg
  9. Black Swan
  10. You Will Meet a Tall Dark Stranger

Nicholas Rapold (The L Magazine)

[commentary]

  1. Carlos
  2. Everyone Else
  3. The Father of My Children
  4. The Oath
  5. Oki’s Movie
  6. Ruhr
  7. The Robber
  8. Shutter Island
  9. The Social Network
  10. Poto Cabengo/Routine Pleasures

Michael Joshua Rowin (The L Magazine)

[commentary]

  1. Our Beloved Motnt of August
  2. Greenberg
  3. Bluebeard
  4. Hadewich
  5. Boxing Gym
  6. The Ghost Writer
  7. White Material
  8. The Portugese Nun
  9. Sweetgrass
  10. Eccentricities of a Blond Hair Girl

Benjamin Strong (The L Magazine)

[commentary]

  1. Film Socialisme
  2. The Autobiography of Nicolae Ceausescu
  3. Carlos
  4. Greenberg
  5. Inspector Bellamy
  6. Everyone Else
  7. Black Swan
  8. The Social Network
  9. Please Give
  10. Splice

Henry Stewart (The L Magazine)

[commentary]

  1. Daddy Longlegs
  2. Life During Wartime
  3. Valhalla Rising
  4. Wild Grass
  5. Black Swan
  6. Shutter Island
  7. NY Export: Opus Jazz
  8. Marwencol
  9. Lourdes
  10. The Kids Are Alright

Jesse Hassenger (The L Magazine)

[commentary]

  1. Inception
  2. Greenberg
  3. The Social Network
  4. Toy Story 3
  5. Black Swan
  6. Scott Pilgrim Vs The World
  7. I Love You Phillip Morris
  8. Fish Tank
  9. The Other Guys
  10. 127 Hours

Ricard Corliss (Time Online)

[commentary]

  1. Toy Story 3
  2. Inside Job
  3. Never Let Me Go
  4. Life During Wartime
  5. The Social Network
  6. Rabbit Hole
  7. Wild Grass
  8. Green Zone
  9. Waiting for Superman
  10. Four Lions

David Edelstein (New York Magazine)

[commentary]

  1. Winter’s Bone
  2. (tied) Client 9: The Rise and Fall of Eliot Spitzer, Inside Job
  3. Please Give
  4. Toy Story 3
  5. Another Year
  6. Mother & Child
  7. Vincere
  8. Exit Through the Gift Shop
  9. Marwencol
  10. Despicable Me

Sight & Sound Magazine

[commentary] [individual critic’s list]

1. “The Social Network” (David Fincher)
2. “Uncle Boonmee Who Can Recall His Past Lives” (Apichatpong Weerasethakul)
3. “Another Year” (Mike Leigh)
4. “Carlos” (Olivier Assayas)
5. “The Arbor” (Clio Barnard)
6. “Winter’s Bone” (Debra Granik)
6. (tied) “I Am Love” (Luca Guadagnino)
8. “The Autobiography of Nicolae Ceausescu” (Andrei Ujica)
8. (tied) “Film Socialisme” (Jean-Luc Godard)
8. (tied) “Nostalgia for the Light” (Patricio Guzman)
8. (tied) “Poetry” (Lee Chang-dong)
8. (tied) “A Prophet” (Jacques Audiard)

Advertisements

2 thoughts on “Rangkuman “Top Ten Films of 2010” (Critics & Bloggers)

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s